Emare and her robe shield

I really like this tale, even though we are right back to treating women like objects. Sadly I don't think that theme will rest up. We do have another situation where the father seems a little too protective or obsessed with his daughter. Why did he feel the need to marry her though? That just weirds me out. Despite her own father banishing her, she seems to roll with the punches and that's throughout the whole story.

Her father treats her as an object and King Galys only looks at her outer beauty to determine that he wants to marry her. Although I did appreciate his kindness in his letter that told his men to still look after her. My question is why didn't Sir Kadore do anything when all of a sudden she was going to be banished? Wouldn't he think something was off? He must have gotten a bad vibe from the queen mother at some point that she was the type to meddle in, it's kind of hard not to recognize someone like that.

I like the robe concept here. I think that it definitely had a major role in saving her life and sort of guiding her maybe. She was weakened by her travels but she wasn't left for dead. She also reached far off places that accepted her, at least at one point. She was also wearing it when she was reunited with the her husband. I also loved how she settled with a merchant and spent years working with her hands instead of being kept above everybody else to just be marveled at like queens and princesses are usually. I didn't care for her to meet with her father again, but I guess it made her happy to be reunited with him.

Thank God the mother was found out to be a lying piece of crap! She brought it on herself. I mean maybe she was bored and didn't want another woman to receive love from her son but what the hell woman. Go find yourself a man, or a hobby for that matter! I really liked this happy ending. Emare deserved to know that her husband did not banish her and her son deserved to know that his father truly loved him.

Sweet Emaré's Sweet Come Back

Emaré must be my favorite tale by far.  In the face of death, Emaré/ Egaré somehow kills everyone with kindness and grace.  I wish I wasn't as petty as I am, because she is an absolute rock-star.  A humble upbringing by Dame Abró was clearly much better than her heathen father.  I find it interesting how no one questions anyone.  There is no "dude wtf" or "why did you replace me with the King of Sicily?"  (ALSO lol at his temporary blindness and instantly blaming it on fairies)

I'm very proud of her to have the strength to tell her father she will not marry him in the name of the Lord.  Still shocked that his first instinct was to cast his own daughter who he's seen for the first time in YEARS to sea with no resources.  But at the same time, I feel like a lot of people make rash decisions as such.

Emaré, now Egaré once she reaches Wales seems to experience one of the greatest fortunes the world could bestow upon her.   Much like our class discussion about the author giving the reader positive/life changing events, but taking away with tragedy (although this is of a higher scale than Sir Orfeo's) I find that it makes me want to keep reading.  Having a healthy boy and living to take care of him, then being cast off to sea AGAIN because of her husband's mom (talk about bad in-laws).

The way she goes about telling, or having Segramore tell them, both her father and husband who they are is extraordinarily eloquent.  She carries no hate in her which I know I would be FIRED UP if anything happened to me even remotely as terrible as that.  I'd say the lesson is to prove by doing and always strive to be the better person (and to raise even better kids).

Ehh...

I'll be honest, I dont think I am a fan of this tale.

Don't get me wrong, I love the whole idea of this fairy world, or underworld because it adds a lot to the story, but i didnt really want to see a happy ending... at all. I feel like all this stuff happened just for it to come full circle and be a happy ending and end how it initially started off. He was king again. I guess the only thing is it took 10 years and a lot can happen in 10 years. The most interesting part of this whole story is when his wife does get taken, after that and all the way to the end i just found myself diappointed with the plot of the story. Somebody needed to die (his wife... or him maybe) 

Although I dont care for the happy ever after ending or the plot I did enjoy the symbolism. For instance in class we talked about diguise and how people who do that are usually people who did wrong. I didnt realize what Sir Orfeo could have done until I thought about it. He ditched his people with no rhyme or reason! So that made a lot of sense. He didnt just come back 10 years later like he was hot s*** again. But with that I am still stuck on this whole idea of a happy ending. His people were accepting after he ditched them 10 years ago... but I mean hey. 

Back to the fairyland idea. I loved it! I love seeing settings like this, especially when they are semi-unexpected. You dont expect fairies to come out of nowhere and take your wife. 😐😐 Things like that dont happen in real life and to be honest I want to escape from reality when I am reading and this does just that. Faries are supposed to be mystical creatures and this captures that. 

Something to Harp About

Well, I've spent a good week tracing my memory for the original story, "Orpheus," and I don't think I've ever heard it, despite how familiar the word Orpheus sounds. That's a shame because I'm really into the Underworld setting, fairies are the only mystical creature that never fail to interest me (this I've known since 5th grade), and "Sir Orfeo" is definitely one of my favorite medieval tales thus far. It would be enriching to read where it came from.

I found myself most attracted to and fascinated by the symbolism imbedded in the tale. Most memorably, this version retains the original symbol of a harp. A harp free associates well in my mind. I think of Greek Gods looking to the Heavens and stringing their harps like they're making love to them - something angelic and passionate. Harps sound like poetry, and with all those strings, it takes a lot of skill to play one. Both Orpheus and Sir Orfeo are known for their mad harp skills. In fact, it's his harping that ultimately grants Sir Orfeo his wife:

Minstrel, your harping pleases me,

So ask whatever it might be,

And generously your boon I'll grant.

Now speak, and tell me what you want.

(Lines 449-452)

Of course, the Fairy King has to let us know he doesn't want to give Sir Orfeo's wife up but that he will, since he just said he'd do anything. What a nice guy! Who knew he was such a man of his word, let alone a man so moved by strings. You know, it's really a surprise that anyone keeps his word when he doesn't want to. If an evil fairy king can keep his word when he doesn't want to, why can't you?

After the Fairy King teaches us to stay true, Sir Orfeo reminds us to stay humble. First of all, this guy and his wife were the king and queen, and they aren't even recognized when they return to Winchester. Okay, maybe the lack of technology and passage of time can explain that one, but Sir Orfeo is still smart enough to remember that he really ditched out on his people, they might not understand why, and they might even hate him, so it's probably not be a good idea to reveal himself in his return without giving it much thought.

Instead, he chills on the outskirts of town and stops by a "beggar's hut by the city wall" (Line 486) to get the inside scoop on his kingdom. Then, he puts on "a suit of borrowed rags" (Line 501) and goes into town with his harp on his back with intent on finding out how loyal his people really are. I have to admit, I was looking forward to some drama in the kingdom upon his return, but once his squire's loyalty is clear, Sir Orfeo reclaims his throne and everything is pretty much happy ever after. Oh well, this anticlimax still teaches me two things:

1. Love deserves your time and energy above all.
2. Those who love you will not stop loving you when you're gone.

Nine Medieval Romances of Magic,re-rhymed in modern English by Marijane Osborn.

A Dream is Kind of a Wish Your Heart Makes

After the discussion we had today in class, I definitely think that viewing this story as kind of the Disney revamp version of Orpheus is the way to go. Even though there is some scary stuff in there (like there is in most Disney movies, let’s be real), the ending is a straight-up crazy happy fairytale. It takes the original Orpheus story and tones down all the super intense stuff, adds in a little heartache, but then comes at you with a comically happy ending that feels just a little too happy.

I feel like the comparison of the underworld to the fairy garden was really interesting, especially in what it can say about our own ideas of goodness and evil. At first glance, it seems like going to the fairy garden would obviously be the thing to do – I mean, even if there is some evil, at least it isn’t an ugly underworld. But when you actually start to think about it more, it’s easy to see that while the underworld is, well, the underworld, the fairy garden clearly seems to have more evil in it, at least in the way that it disguises itself as a paradise.

Reading this story, I was reminded of the early Disney cartoon The Goddess of Spring, which came out in the 1930s and has vivid images of a cheery garden, and then of course the underworld (and a pretty weird version of the devil in my opinion). The more I think about it, the more it is clear that that cartoon clearly has connections to this story. I haven’t watched the short in a while, but I think watching it and comparing it to my earlier comment about this whole story being like a Disney remake would be a super cool thing to do.

Moral of the story is that the time has come for Disney to make a new version of Sir Orfeo for this new generation. Or maybe they could just do Orpheus, and we could all compare that movie to Sir Orfeo and see how many similarities there are. I think viewing the two stories as essentially one and the same is a super interesting way to look at it, especially when we see what specific changes were made, and what ideas stayed the same. I’m not sure which one I like more (I mean, I appreciate the tragedy of Orpheus… but also I love me some happy endings), but I think looking at them next to one another can be really interesting.

Poor John!

The Miller's Tale is a hot-ass mess! Between this old man marrying an 18-year-old, butts being stuck outside of windows, and the promise of a fake flood – I couldn’t help but laugh.

I enjoyed the fact that as readers, we get to be in on the jokes that are played out. I knew this chick Alisoun was going to be unfaithful from the start; their age is the biggest indicator. She was quickly wooed by Nicholas and falls in love. I think she plays the most major role in deceit, by convincing her husband that a fake flood was headed their way so that she could spend a night in his bed with her lover.

John, poor, poor John. The only honest one in this whole charade. I can’t help but feel sorry for the guy! He tried to protect his wife from drowning, and in the end, he’s made out to be a fool! He’ll never be taken seriously again by his neighbors. Nicholas and Alisoun make everyone believe he’s crazy when they’re the ones getting it on in John’s bed!

To me, there’s no sense of true love in this story; it’s all about sex. Absolon tries to make us believe that he wants to court Alisoun, but all he’s interested in is sex. This dude got what he deserved if you ask me. Trying to kiss another man’s wife (even if she is committing adultery) is wrong! I’m glad he has to kiss ass, personally.


John is the only poor bastard I feel for in this story, even though his love for his wife was somewhat misguided, he still had good intentions. In correlation to Nicholas’ and Alisoun’s fucked up moral codes, John’s devotion to his wife is endearing!

Nevertheless, I enjoyed this story quite a bit. My favorite so far!

Classic Drunk Uncle

Let me start out by saying that the Miller's tale reminds me so much of Saturday Night Live's "Drunk Uncle" bit with Bobby Moynihan and I love it! If you haven't seen them, do yourself a favor and look up videos, they are hilarious!

I think the Miller's tale adds some humor to the story and breaks up the tale nicely even if the people may reject him telling the story out of the social status order, but oh well! The Miller really seems like he wants to basically shit on the knight's tale and give a more graphic, rude, and harsh story that shows people in a different light.

The Miller's characteristics for Alisoun were extremely different than we are used to hearing. I looked up "she is a piggesyne for any lord to leggen in his bede". "Piggesyne" seems to be a tender chicken?  He compares her with animal characteristics which is strange and maybe a little offensive. He also describes her with having a lustful eye but you can't really argue that she doesn't after she tricked her husband just so she could have a night alone with Nicholas.

The story took an unexpected turn in my opinion with all the talk about God. I liked how John thought he deserved his madness after poking around with God's privacy. I thought it was funny however that when Nicholas told John about the flood that was to come, John was completely on board with it. I did feel bad because he wanted to protect his wife, Alisoun who was going to stab him in the back anyway.

Poor Absolon, but then not really. This was a classic Pepe Le Pew and Penelope Pussycat situation. He seemed a little annoying to me when he was poking his nose where it should not have been. I guess it is sweet to have an admirer but he must have known she was married so it takes a lot of courage to snoop around her house and ask for a kiss from her. I think he got what he deserved, but Nicholas passing gas in his face? Maybe a bit much but hey it's fitting when the Miller is telling the story. 

I thought that Alisoun and Nicholas were going to be found out and that they would be the ones humiliated in front of the town, but it was poor John who got laughed at again. Not only was his wife a liar and a cheater, she flipped it around on him so that everyone would think he was crazy! I guess they weren't as dumb as I thought.